Do After Eight Mints Get Smaller?

Yes, many fans swear that After Eight mints have gotten smaller over the years. The boxes look thinner, the individual mints feel lighter, and the chocolate sheet seems to have shrunk. While the brand hasn’t officially admitted to a size reduction, packaging changes and net weight decreases point to a classic case of shrinkflation.

Are After Eight Mints Actually Getting Smaller?

After Eight mints, made by Nestlé, have been a holiday favorite since 1962. Over the past decade, careful observers have noticed that the dark chocolate mint wafers appear to have shrunk. Comparing photos from the 1990s to today shows a noticeable difference in the dimensions of the foil-wrapped mints. The standard box now holds fewer ounces for roughly the same price. This is a common practice known as shrinkflation – reducing product size while keeping the price the same.

In 2020 and 2021, British newspapers reported that Nestlé had reduced the weight of the classic 200g box to 170g. That is a 15% drop. The number of mints in the box also decreased in some versions. While the mint itself may not have shrunk in every dimension, the overall package certainly holds less chocolate.

What Does the Packaging Say? Check the Net Weight

The easiest way to spot size changes is by reading the net weight on the box. Here is a quick comparison of the classic After Eight mint box over the years:

The exact numbers vary by region and product line. But the trend is clear: you are getting less chocolate and fewer mints for the same price. The individual mint size may have also been trimmed by a few millimeters. Some fans report that the mint round is not as wide as it used to be, and the chocolate coating is thinner.

Why Do People Think After Eight Mints Are Smaller?

Beyond actual weight loss, there are perceptual reasons why they seem smaller. The packaging has changed over the years. The cardboard box became sleeker, with less space between the sleeve and the inner tray. The foil wrap around each mint also got a bit tighter, making the mint look smaller. Also, the contrast between the dark chocolate and the white mint fondant creates an optical illusion – the white center appears to take up more relative space if the chocolate layer thins out. It is a mix of real reduction and visual trickery.

• Thinner chocolate coating – less chocolate means less volume.
• Tighter packaging – less empty space around the mint can make it look puny.
• Recipe tweaks – some batches have a higher ratio of mint filling to chocolate, which can change the perceived size.
• Inconsistent manufacturing – mints from different factories may vary in size by a few grams.

Have After Eight Changed Their Recipe or Size Recently?

Nestlé does not openly discuss recipe or size changes. However, in 2021, the company updated the packaging to a slightly more rectangular shape and reduced the weight of the standard box from 200g to 170g. That change was widely reported in the UK and US. The ingredient list remained nearly the same: dark chocolate, sugar, butter, cream, mint oil. But the proportion of chocolate to mint fondant may have shifted. Some fans claim the chocolate is less rich now, but that is harder to measure than size. The official Nestlé statement often points to changes in “consumer preferences” or “packaging efficiency” when questioned.

How Does Shrinkflation Affect Chocolate Products Like After Eight?

Shrinkflation is common across the chocolate industry. Candy bars, chocolate boxes, and even baking chips have all been downsized over the years. After Eight is not alone. Here are other examples of shrinkflation in the chocolate world:

• Milky Way bar – reduced from 58g to 51g.
• Terry’s Chocolate Orange – weight dropped from 175g to 157g.
• Quality Street – the number of chocolates per tin dropped while tin size stayed similar.
• Lindt truffles – some boxes now contain fewer truffles for the same price.

Manufacturers do this to protect profit margins when cocoa, sugar, and packaging costs rise. For a product like After Eight, which relies on thin wafers, even a 2–3mm reduction in diameter saves a lot of chocolate across millions of boxes.

Are There Different Sizes of After Eight Mints?

Yes, the product line includes several sizes. The classic box holds around 25–30 mints. But there are also gift boxes (e.g., 300g), mini sachets for travel, and bulk bags sold at warehouse clubs. The individual mint size is fairly consistent across retail boxes. The gift box may have larger mints or thicker chocolate, but that is rare. The standard mint sold in supermarkets is the one that has shrunk. The bulk bag mints can sometimes be slightly smaller or thinner because they are made for high-volume sales. Always check the net weight per mint to know if you are getting a fair deal.

How to Compare After Eight Mint Sizes Yourself

If you want to see if your box has shrunk, you can do a simple test at home. All you need is a kitchen scale that measures grams accurately. Weigh a single mint (unwrap it first). A traditional After Eight mint weighed roughly 6.7–7.0 grams. If your mint weighs 5.8 grams or less, it has likely shrunk. You can also measure the diameter with a ruler – it should be about 42mm across. Any less than 40mm indicates downsizing.

For accurate results, a digital kitchen scale with 0.1g precision makes it easy to check net weight and single-mint weight. This scale works well for baking and portion control too.

What About After Eight Dark Chocolate Thins? Are They Different?

The Dark Chocolate Thins version is a separate product that uses a darker chocolate (70% cocoa). Those thins have always been slightly smaller and thinner than the classic mint. However, they too may have experienced some downsizing in recent years. The standard After Eight mint is the one most people notice shrinking. The Dark Chocolate Thins have less sugar and a more intense cocoa flavor. But the size trend applies to both – portion reduction is common in the premium chocolate segment.

Do Other Mint Chocolates Suffer from the Same Issue?

Yes, many mint chocolate products have downsized. Andes mints, for example, have had their thin mints shrink slightly in thickness. Ghirardelli squares have also seen weight reductions. Even fresh mint chocolate products like those from small candy shops may increase prices rather than shrink. The main takeaway: if a product has been on shelves for decades, there is a good chance it has been through a size reduction. After Eight is just one example of this industry-wide practice.

Will After Eight Mints Keep Getting Smaller?

Probably. As cocoa prices rise and inflation persists, further downsizing is likely. Nestlé may reduce the count per box or trim the mint dimensions by another millimeter. They could also move to thinner wrappers or less packaging to cut costs. Some fans worry that the classic After Eight experience will continue to degrade. The only way to fight back is to vote with your wallet – buy smaller quantities, wait for sales, or switch to store brands that may offer better value. But the brand’s loyal following may ensure it stays around, even in reduced form.

How to Get the Best Value for Your Money with After Eight

If you love After Eight mints but hate paying for a shrinking product, here are some practical tips:

• Check the unit price – Look at the price per 100g on the shelf label. Compare different box sizes.
• Buy in bulk – Large cartons or bags often have a lower unit price. A bulk pack of After Eight mints can save you money per mint.
• Wait for holiday sales – After Christmas and Easter often have deep discounts.
• Weigh the box – If you have a scale, weigh the full box and compare to the net weight on the label. If the difference is large, you are getting less chocolate.
• Consider store brands – Some supermarkets make their own mint chocolate thins that are bigger and cheaper.

Using a small measuring ruler can also help you verify that you are getting the size you expected.

Is the Taste the Same Even If They Are Smaller?

Most fans say the taste remains delicious. The chocolate is still smooth, and the mint filling is refreshing. The size change does not affect the flavor profile. However, some people feel that a thinner chocolate layer changes the texture – the crunch is less satisfying. Still, if you enjoy the combination of dark chocolate and mint, After Eight mints remain a tasty treat. Just be aware that you might need to eat two instead of one to get the same satisfaction as years past.

To sum up, yes, After Eight mints have gotten smaller as part of shrinkflation. You can check net weight, weigh your mints, and buy strategically to get the best value. The flavor is still there, but the portion is not what it used to be.

Twitter Facebook Reddit Pinterest